Carmelita Cookies : 5 Star Classic With Gooey Layers

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

If you’ve never tasted Carmelita Cookies, you’re in for a real treat. These buttery bars bring together chewy oats, gooey caramel, and melty chocolate layered to perfection in a recipe that feels like it came straight from Grandma’s kitchen. In this post, we’ll walk through the heartwarming story behind this dessert, the simple ingredients you’ll need, smart baking tips, and how to serve or store them for any occasion. Whether you’re baking for a crowd or just craving something sweet, these cookie bars promise to be the comforting classic you’ll reach for again and again.

Table of Contents

A Kentucky Kitchen Favorite

The first time I made Carmelita Cookies, I was flipping through one of those old church cookbooks with my mom the kind with hand-written notes in the margins and pages sticky from years of love. We landed on a recipe labeled “Carmelitas,” and I knew it had to be good just from the name. Caramel, oats, chocolate… what could go wrong?

I mixed the dough while my youngest stirred the caramel sauce on the stove. The smell alone brought the neighbors peeking in. When we finally cut into them, still warm from the oven, the bars oozed with caramel and melted chocolate chips nestled between crisp, buttery layers of oats. That was the moment these bars earned a permanent place in my recipe box and in every bake sale, holiday tray, and weeknight dessert rotation since.

Around here in Louisville, where recipes get passed down with love and a little bit of sass, Carmelita Cookies are the kind of dessert that says, “I made this just for you.” Whether you’re bringing them to church potluck or slicing some up to go with coffee, they’re always met with empty plates.

Two of my most-visited recipes Magnolia Banana Pudding Copycat and Oreo Dump Cake share that same spirit: simple ingredients, cozy flavors, and a whole lot of heart. Carmelita Cookies fit right in.

What Makes Carmelita Cookies So Special

Let’s be honest, there’s no shortage of cookie bar recipes floating around. But these? These are something else. What sets Carmelita Cookies apart is their unbeatable texture. You get that soft, chewy bite from brown sugar and oats, a little crunch from the baked crust, and then a rich, sticky layer of chocolate and caramel that melts in your mouth.

Even better, the ingredients are all things you likely have in your pantry right now: oats, flour, brown sugar, butter, chocolate chips, and store-bought caramel. They’re easy to throw together on a Tuesday but decadent enough for the holidays. Plus, you bake them in a single pan and slice into squares less mess, more cookie.

You can dress them up with a sprinkle of sea salt or keep them classic. Either way, Carmelita Cookies are the kind of recipe you’ll want to make a double batch of one for the table and one for the freezer (or let’s be real, your secret stash).

Ingredients for making Carmelita Cookies — Pantry staples for the perfect batch of Carmelita Cookies

Simple Ingredients, Big Flavor

Pantry Staples That Deliver Every Time

What I love most about Carmelita Cookies is that they don’t ask for anything fancy. These bars come together with the kind of ingredients many of us already have stocked in our cabinets and when they bake up, you’d never guess how easy they were to make.

Here’s a quick breakdown of the core ingredients and why each one matters:

Ingredient	Purpose
Old-fashioned oats	Provides chew and structure
All-purpose flour	Holds the crust together
Brown sugar	Adds moisture and a deep caramel flavor
Salted butter	Binds the crust and brings richness
Caramel sauce	Creates the gooey center
Chocolate chips	Melts into a sweet, rich layer

If you’re a fan of layered textures like in my Churro Cheesecake Bars or the sandwich-style Homemade Oreos, you’ll feel right at home with how these ingredients work together.

Smart Swaps for Every Pantry

These cookie bars are incredibly forgiving, which makes them perfect for tweaking to fit your diet or whatever you have on hand. Here are a few tried-and-true substitution ideas:

Gluten-Free: Swap the all-purpose flour for a 1:1 gluten-free baking blend and make sure your oats are certified gluten-free. No one will know the difference.
Dairy-Free: Use plant-based butter and opt for dairy-free caramel and chocolate chips (several brands make great ones now).
Nutty Twist: Add ½ cup of chopped pecans or walnuts for a toasted crunch. It plays beautifully with the caramel.
Coconut Love: Fold in shredded coconut for a tropical hint especially good if you enjoy gooey bars with a twist.

You can also experiment with flavors try butterscotch chips or a sprinkle of cinnamon in the crust for a cozy spin. Like any good comfort recipe, Carmelita Cookies invite you to make them your own.

How to Make Carmelita Cookies Step by Step

Layering the Goodness: Your Roadmap to Cookie Bar Bliss

Making Carmelita Cookies isn’t just easy it’s genuinely fun. The beauty is in the layers. You press the oat mixture into the bottom, spoon over rich caramel and chocolate, then top it with more oat crumble. It’s rustic, cozy, and foolproof when you follow this flow:

Prep your pan: Line an 8×8 or 9×9 pan with parchment paper. Leave overhang so you can lift the bars out later without breaking them. This step matters trust me.
Mix the crust: In a bowl, stir together melted butter, brown sugar, oats, flour, baking soda, and salt until crumbly but moist.
Press & bake: Press half the mixture firmly into the pan and bake it for about 10 minutes. This helps create a sturdy base that won’t fall apart when you slice it later.
Melt caramel: While the crust bakes, melt your caramel with a splash of heavy cream (or milk) on the stove or microwave until pourable.
Layer it up: Remove the crust from the oven, scatter chocolate chips across, pour caramel over the top, then crumble the rest of the oat mixture on last.
Final bake: Return the pan to the oven for another 15–20 minutes, until the top is golden and edges are bubbling slightly.
Cool completely: This part is hard really hard but don’t skip it. Let them cool at room temp or chill them for cleaner cuts.

For an ultra-gooey center like in Homemade Cosmic Brownies or Watergate Cake, I like to underbake by just a minute or two and let the bars set in the fridge.

Common Mistakes You’ll Want to Avoid

Even easy recipes come with a few traps. Here’s how to keep your Carmelita Cookies from turning into a sticky regret:

Cutting too soon: Warm caramel is molten and messy. Cooling = clean bars.
Skipping parchment: You’ll fight with the pan if you don’t line it. Always leave overhang.
Overbaking: The top should look golden but not dry. If it bubbles at the edges and jiggles slightly in the center, you’re golden.
Using runny caramel: If your sauce is too thin, it’ll soak into the crust. Go for thick, creamy caramel that sits in place.

These bars are pretty forgiving, though. Even the “messy” ones get devoured fast. And if they fall apart? Call them a caramel crumble and serve it over vanilla ice cream. No one will complain.

Serving, Storing, and Gifting Ideas

Cozy Ways to Serve Carmelita Cookies

There’s no wrong time to pull out a tray of Carmelita Cookies. They’re just as welcome at a church potluck as they are on a holiday dessert table. The caramel melts into the chocolate, the oat crust crisps just enough, and that chewy bite? Pure comfort.

Carmelita Cookies ready to serve with milk — Carmelita Cookies stacked and ready to enjoy with a cold glass of milk

Here are a few of my favorite ways to serve them:

Warm from the microwave: Pop a bar in the microwave for 10–15 seconds. The caramel gets gooey, the chocolate softens, and it pairs perfectly with a mug of coffee or cold milk.
Dessert platter centerpiece: Stack them next to bowls of Booty Dip or wedges of Black Forest Cake Revival for a dessert spread that brings smiles to all ages.
Lunchbox treat: They hold up well in a lunch container and feel more special than a store-bought cookie.
Post-dinner sweet bite: I like to cut them smaller for just a nibble after a weeknight meal. They hit the spot without going overboard.

Their buttery richness means they satisfy quickly but that doesn’t stop folks from coming back for seconds.

Make-Ahead, Store, or Gift Like a Pro

Can you freeze Carmelita Cookies? Absolutely and they hold up beautifully. In fact, I often double the batch just so I can freeze half. Here’s how to keep them fresh:

Room temp: Store in an airtight container for up to 5 days. Separate layers with wax paper to prevent sticking.
Freezer friendly: Wrap tightly in plastic or foil, place in a freezer bag, and label with the date. They’ll keep for 2–3 months. Thaw at room temp or warm in a toaster oven for that “just baked” feel.

And for gifting?

Mason jar stacks: Cut into small squares and stack in a wide-mouth mason jar with a cute ribbon and tag.
Brown bag bundles: Slide into wax paper sleeves, tuck into a brown paper lunch bag, and fold down the top with a sticker or holiday seal.
Cookie tin surprise: Add them to a tin alongside peanut butter blossoms or sugar cookies for a nostalgic, bakery-style presentation.

Homemade desserts like Carmelita Cookies bring more than just flavor they bring warmth. Whether you’re freezing a stash for future cravings or wrapping them up for your favorite neighbor, these bars are always a welcome treat.

Frequently Asked Questions About Carmelita Cookies

What is a Carmelita cookie?

A Carmelita cookie is a soft and chewy dessert bar made with layers of buttery oat crust, chocolate chips, and thick caramel filling. These bars are known for their rich texture and gooey bite perfect for bake sales, holidays, or everyday sweet cravings.

What are Carmelita bars?

Carmelita bars are essentially the same as Carmelita Cookies, just in bar form. They start with an oat-based dough, filled with caramel and chocolate, then topped with more oat crumble and baked until golden. After cooling, they’re sliced into bars, making them ideal for serving or storing.

What is Michelle Obama’s favorite cookie?

While Michelle Obama has shared a White and Dark Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe in the past, there’s no official record of her declaring a favorite. But if she ever tried these Carmelita Cookies, we think they’d make the list!

What are the top 3 best selling Girl Scout cookies?

The top three best-selling Girl Scout cookies are Thin Mints, Samoas (Caramel deLites), and Tagalongs (Peanut Butter Patties). While Carmelita Cookies aren’t part of the lineup, their caramel-chocolate-oat combo gives the classics a run for their money.

Conclusion: A Sweet That Feels Like Home

Whether you’re baking from memory or trying something new, Carmelita Cookies are the kind of recipe that wraps you in warmth from the first bite. With simple ingredients, layered flavors, and an easy-to-follow method, they fit right into the heart of Gemmir Kitchen’s style comfort made simple.

I’ve served these at family reunions, tucked them into lunchboxes, and gifted them during the holidays, and they never fail to bring joy. If you’re looking for a dessert that feels like a hug and tastes like something out of a nostalgic church cookbook this one’s for you. And if you do bake a batch, I’d love to see how they turned out! Come say hi and share your photos over on my Facebook page it’s where the Gemmir Kitchen family keeps growing.

Carmelita Cookies : 5 Star Classic With Gooey Layers